Community Governance Review
Stroud District Council is carrying out a community governance review pursuant to the provisions of the Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007, and other relevant statutory provisions.
The review will have regard to the ‘Guidance on Community Governance Reviews’ issued by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and the Local Government Boundary Commission for England. The aim of the review is to ensure that the arrangements for community governance across the district reflect ‘the identities and interests of the community in the area’ and are ‘effective and convenient’.
The review will be conducted with the Terms of Reference contained in this document.
Community Governance Review of the Stroud District – Final Recommendations
- Final Recommendations approved at full Council on the 18 July 2019
- Maps relating to the Final Recommendations
- Final Recommendations Report for full Council – 18 July 2019
- Council meeting minutes - 18 July 2019
- Community governance review stage 2 consultation responses.pdf
The Council will now draw up the necessary Reorganisation of Community Governance Order for the changes to come into effect on the 1 April 2020.
Community Governance Review of the Stroud District Draft Recommendations
- Summary of draft proposals.pdf (223 KB)
- Community Governance Review Draft Recommendations February 2019.pdf (8.1 MB)
- CGR Initial submissions received - Appendix A.pdf (6.8 MB)
- Community governance draft recommendation consultation responses
- Draft Recommendation maps by Parish
- Survey responses by Parish
Have your say
All of the consultation periods have now closed
The initial consultation opened on the 3 September and closed on the 26 November
Following the publication of the draft recommendations on the 18 February, a further consultation period was held until the 6 May.
What is a Community governance Review?
A Community Governance Review is the process used to consider whether existing parish arrangements should be changed in any way. This includes:
- Altering the boundaries of existing parishes;
- Changing the names of existing parishes;
- Creating a new parish or abolishing an existing parish;
- Creating or abolishing parish councils;
- The electoral arrangements for parish councils (including the number of councillors and arrangements for parish warding);
- The grouping or de-grouping or parish councils (and consequential changes to their electoral arrangements);
- The ‘style’ of a parish (enabling an area to be known as a town, community, neighbourhood or village rather than a parish)
Who is carrying out the review?
Stroud District Council is statutorily responsible for carrying out the review. The conduct of the review will be overseen by the Council’s Community Governance Review Members Group, which includes councillors from all political groups. Formal decisions as to the terms of reference for the review and the recommendations arising from the review will be made by full Council.
What is the area under review?
The whole of the Stroud District is included in the scope of the Community Governance Review. However, we are particularly keen to hear from local people and parish councils with proposals as to where and how they believe parish arrangements should be reviewed.
Why is the Council carrying out a community governance review?
In 2016, the Local Government Boundary Commission for England made changes to a number of district wards which resulted in a small number of anomalies in the relationship between the district wards and parish boundaries. A Community Governance Review provides the opportunity to consider whether changes should be made to parish arrangements in response to these and other issues raised by local people. It is intended that any new parish arrangements will take effect at the May 2020 local elections.
Furthermore, the statutory guidance indicates that it is good practice to review community governance arrangements every 10-15 years.
How will the review work?
We are carrying out two phases of consultations on parish arrangements in the Stroud District. The first phase of consultation asks for proposals on changes to existing parish arrangements. We will then use all responses received during this period of consultation to draw up draft recommendations for changes to parish arrangements in the district. We will then hold a second phase of consultation on these draft recommendations, during which time we will invite comments and any proposed alternatives to the areas where we have recommended a change.
- The first period of consultation will take place from Monday 3 September 2018 to Monday 26 November 2018.
- Following the close of the first period of consultation, the draft set of recommendations will be published on Monday 18 February 2019.
- These draft recommendations will then be the subject of a second period of consultation, which will run from Monday 18 February 2019 to Monday 6 May 2019.
- Following the end of the second period of consultation, all comments received will be considered against the draft recommendations. The final set of recommendations will then be submitted to full Council in July 2019.
- It is intended that the final recommendations, which will include any changes to the current parish arrangements in the Stroud District, will be implemented in time for the May 2020 elections.
The Council will make a Reorganisation of Community Governance Order in order to implement these recommendations. Such an Order may cover ‘consequential matters’ required to give effect to the Order, such as the transfer of property or other assets, the setting of precepts for new parishes and staffing matters.
What matters will the review focus on?
The final recommendations made at the end of the review will seek to ensure that community governance across the district:
- Reflects the identities and interests of the community in that area
- Is effective and convenient
When responding to the consultation on parish arrangements, you should ensure that your proposal takes account of these two criteria.
The Council also has to take into account other arrangements for community representation or engagement in the area.
In considering the electoral arrangements of the parishes in its area, the Council is required to consider any change in the number of distribution of electors which is likely to occur in the period of five years beginning with the day the review starts.
Unlike the Local Government Boundary Commission for England’s review of district ward arrangements, there is no provision in legislation that each parish councillor should represent (as nearly as possible) the same number of electors. However, the government guidance reiterates the Commission’s belief that it is not in the interests of effective and convenient local government to have significant difference in levels of representation between different wards in the same parish. Additionally, any recommendations made by the review must adhere to the legal minimum number of parish councillors for any parish council, which is five. There is no legal maximum number of parish councillors.
Who will we consult?
The Council is required to consult with local government electors living in the Stroud District as well as any other individuals and organisations (including local authorities such as parish councils) who ‘appear to have an interest in the review’.
The Council must take into account all representations that it receives during the review’s periods of consultation and will make all representations available for public viewing.
How will we consult?
We wrote to all parish councils and identified umbrella organisations (including Gloucestershire Association of Town and Parish Councils) before the start of the first period of consultation, inviting them to submit their views. The same process will be followed with the second period of consultation.
We have also publicised the review on our website through our internal communication channels and on our social media platforms to engage with residents, community groups and other stakeholders and will do so again for the next consultation period.
What is a community governance review?
A Community Governance Review is a way for district councils to make sure that, at parish level, governance arrangements are working as efficiently and effectively as they should be. This is achieved by asking the public, parish councils and any interested parties whether they feel their communities are suitably represented and whether parish councils would like to see any changes made to their current governance arrangements.
We have the power to undertake such reviews under Part 4 of the Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007 and the relevant national guidance document.
What can a Community Governance Review do?
- A Community Governance Review can make a number of changes to parish councils when there is clear evidence to do so:
- Creating, merging, altering or abolishing parishes;
- Change electoral arrangements for parishes including the ordinary year of an election, number of parish councillors and changes to parish wards;
- Convert a parish council to a parish meeting;
- Change the name or the style of a parish/town council or parish meeting; and
- Group parishes together under a common parish.
Why are we doing a Community Governance Review?
It is good practice to conduct a review of parish council governance arrangements very 10 to 15 years. However, there is no record of us undertaking such a review. A number of changes have impacted on parish councils in recent years, including the changes to district ward boundaries made in 2016. It was felt that now would be a good time to make sure that governance arrangements were working as well as they could be and to make sure that any changes can be put in place before the next elections in May 2020.
What can’t a Community Governance Review do?
A Community Governance Review cannot:
- Change the number of district or county councillors;
- Change a district or county council ward boundaries;
- Change the amount of money that a parish council raises through your council tax (know as ‘precept’);
- Change individual parish councillors; and
- Create a unitary authority.
What are the timescales?
We agreed to undertake the review in July 2018 and have officially published the terms of reference on the 3 September 2018. We now have 12 months to complete the review and agree on any proposed changes.
We are going to be undertaking two phases of consultation in Stroud:
- 3 September 2018 to 26 November 2018 – Phase 1 Consultation: We will be writing to all Parish/Town Councils and Parish Meetings to explain what the review is, why we are doing it and to ask them whether they would be interested in making any changes. We will also be considering population growth forecasts and consulting with key stakeholders including local residents, Gloucestershire Council, Cotswold District Council and the Gloucestershire Association of Parish and Town Councils (GAPTC);
- December 2018 to February 2019 – Interim report writing: Following the closure of the consultation, we will develop an interim report that will include recommendations for changes to parishes;
- 18 February 2019 to 6 May 2019 – Phase 2 Consultation: We will work directly with the areas shortlisted in the interim report to see what local parishes and residents think of our recommendations. We may make changes to our recommendations depending on the responses and evidence we receive during this round of consultation;
- May 2019 to July 2019 – Final Report: We will develop a final report and set of recommendations after Phase 2 of the consultation; and
- July 2019 – The final report and recommendations will be discussed and considered by full Council in July 2018. Following Council’s consideration of the final report, we will make an Order to give effect to any changes to local parishes which will come into force on 1 April 2020 in time for the May 2020 elections.
Who makes the final decision on any changes?
We will need to consider any comments and evidence received as part of the consultation process and will have the final say on any recommendations.
What if we don’t agree with the recommendations?
Whilst we will listen to all representations received, it is ultimately up to us to make the final decision in relation to how community governance should be undertaken.
What role do parish councils perform?
Parish councils are the most local form of government. They collect money from Council Tax payers (via the district council) known as a "precept" and this is used to invest in the area to improve services or facilities. Parish councils can take different forms but usually are made up of local people who stand for election as parish councillors to represent their area. They can be the voice of the local community and work with other tiers of government and external organisations to co-ordinate and deliver services and work to improve the quality of life in the area.
What are grouped parishes?
It may best be considered as a working alliance of parishes that have come together under a common parish council, with the electors of each of the grouped parishes electing a designated number of councillors to the council. It has been found to be an effective way of ensuring parish government for small parishes that might otherwise be unviable as separate units, while otherwise guaranteeing their separate community identity.
The council recognises that the grouping of parishes needs to be compatible with the retention of community interests and notes the government's guidance that "it would be inappropriate for it to be used to build artificially large units under single parish councils."A grouping order is permitted under Section 11 of the Local Government Act 1972.
Parishes or towns can be divided into wards for the purpose of electing councillors. Again, this could depend upon the size and make up of a proposed council. The government guidance requires that consideration be given to the number of and distribution of local government electors which could make a single election of councillors impractical or inconvenient or it may be desirable for areas within the town or parish to be separately represented.
The government's guidance is that "the warding of parishes in largely rural areas that are based predominantly on a single centrally-located village may not be justified. Conversely, warding may be appropriate where the parish encompasses a number of villages with separate identities, a village with a large rural hinterland or where, on the edges of towns, there has been some urban overspill into the parish."
What is a community governance order?
The review will be completed when the council adopts a Reorganisation of Community Governance Order. The Order will specify when it will take effect for financial and administrative purposes and when the electoral arrangements for a new or existing parish council will come into force
Copies of this Order, the map(s) that show the effects of the order in detail and the document(s) which set out the reasons for the decisions that the council has taken (including where it has decided to make no change following a review), will be deposited at the council's offices and website.
In accordance with the guidance issued by the government, the council will issue maps to illustrate each recommendation at a scale that will not normally be smaller than 1:10,000. These maps will be deposited with the Secretary of State at the Department of Communities and Local Government and at the council’s offices. Prints will also be supplied, in accordance with the regulations, to Ordnance Survey, the Registrar General, the Land Registry, the Valuation Office Agency, the Boundary Commission for England and the Electoral Commission.
What do "electoral arrangements" mean?
An important part of our review will comprise giving consideration to electoral arrangements. The term covers the way in which a council is constituted for the parish. It covers:
- The ordinary year in which elections are held;
- The number of councillors to be elected to the council;
- The division (or not) of the parish into wards for the purpose of electing councillors;
- The number and boundaries of any such wards;
- The number of councillors to be elected for any such ward; and
- The name of any such ward. The government's guidance is that "each area should be considered on its own merits, having regard to its population, geography and the pattern of communities," and therefore the council is prepared to pay particular attention to existing levels of representation, the broad pattern of existing council sizes which have stood the test of time and the take-up of seats at elections in its consideration of this matter. The Aston Business School found the following levels of representation to the good running of a council:
- Parishes wishing to increase numbers must give strong reasons for doing so. The number of parish or town councillors for each council must be not less than five but can be greater. However, each parish grouped under a common parish council must have at least one parish councillor.
- Is there an ideal size for a parish council?
Less than 500
2,501 – 10,000
10,001 – 20,000
More than 20,000
The government has a commitment to improve the capacity of the parish structure to deliver better services and to represent the community's interests. Therefore, the council is anxious to ensure that parishes should be viable and should possess a precept that enables them to actively and effectively promote the wellbeing of their residents and to contribute to the real provision of services in their areas in an economic and efficient manner.
It will be desirable for parish or town council boundaries to be readily identifiable. This can be by reference to physical features or may follow adopted electoral ward boundaries in the district. Any changes should also take into account population shifts or additional development that may have affected community identity.